Stones Best for Engagement Rings

stones must be purchased with a Midwinter Co. setting
stones must be purchased with a Midwinter Co. setting
Filter

Sort by
  • Featured
  • Most relevant
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
91 products found
2 Columns 3 Columns 4 Columns List

Date, new to old
  • Featured
  • Most relevant
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
  1. 2-3 carat
  2. Clear all
2.12 Carat Blue Pear Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BPS212
2.12 Carat Blue Pear Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BPS212

2.12 Carat Blue Pear Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BPS212

$2,925.00 USD
$3,250.00 USD
2.15 Carat Black Emerald Cut Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code NBE215
2.15 Carat Black Emerald Cut Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code NBE215

2.15 Carat Black Emerald Cut Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code NBE215

$2,295.00 USD
$2,550.00 USD
2.12 Carat Teal Marquise Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code TMS212
2.12 Carat Teal Marquise Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code TMS212

2.12 Carat Teal Marquise Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code TMS212

$1,550.00 USD
2.62 Carat Cobalt Blue Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BOS262
2.62 Carat Cobalt Blue Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BOS262

2.62 Carat Cobalt Blue Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BOS262

$2,565.00 USD
$2,850.00 USD
2.51 Carat Teal Green Marquise Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code TGMS251 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.51 Carat Teal Green Marquise Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code TGMS251 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.51 Carat Teal Green Marquise Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code TGMS251

$5,265.00 USD
$5,850.00 USD
CAELEN (J) 2.09 Carat Dark and Clear Elongated Hexagon Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code DCH209 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
CAELEN (J) 2.09 Carat Dark and Clear Elongated Hexagon Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code DCH209 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.09 Carat Dark and Clear Elongated Hexagon Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code DCH209

$2,925.00 USD
$3,250.00 USD
2.02 Carat Teal Elongated Cushion Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code TECS202 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.02 Carat Teal Elongated Cushion Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code TECS202 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.02 Carat Teal Elongated Cushion Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code TECS202

$2,385.00 USD
$2,650.00 USD
CAELEN (J) 2.18 Carat Yellow-Green Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code MCOS218 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
CAELEN (J) 2.18 Carat Yellow-Green Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code MCOS218 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.18 Carat Yellow-Green Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code MCOS218

$2,025.00 USD
$2,250.00 USD
CAELEN (J) 2.07 Carat Bicolor Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BCOS207 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
CAELEN (J) 2.07 Carat Bicolor Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BCOS207 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.07 Carat Bicolor Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BCOS207

$3,195.00 USD
$3,550.00 USD
2.65 Carat Color Change Periwinkle Marquise Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code PMS265 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.65 Carat Color Change Periwinkle Marquise Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code PMS265 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.65 Carat Color Change Periwinkle Marquise Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code PMS265

$5,175.00 USD
$5,750.00 USD
CAELEN (J) 2.06 Carat Certified Lab Grown Marquise Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code LGM206 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
CAELEN (J) 2.06 Carat Certified Lab Grown Marquise Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code LGM206 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.06 Carat Certified Lab Grown Marquise Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code LGM206

$2,025.00 USD
$2,250.00 USD
CAELEN (J) 2.04 Carat Green Cushion Cut Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code GCS204 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
CAELEN (J) 2.04 Carat Green Cushion Cut Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code GCS204 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.04 Carat Green Cushion Cut Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code GCS204

$2,295.00 USD
$2,550.00 USD
CAELEN (J) 2.87 Carat Certified Lab Grown Oval Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code LGO287 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
CAELEN (J) 2.87 Carat Certified Lab Grown Oval Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code LGO287 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.87 Carat Certified Lab Grown Oval Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code LGO287

$2,295.00 USD
$2,550.00 USD
2.81 Carat Cornflower Blue Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BOS281 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.81 Carat Cornflower Blue Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BOS281 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.81 Carat Cornflower Blue Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BOS281

$2,115.00 USD
$2,350.00 USD
2.66 Carat Vibrant Blue Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BOS266 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.66 Carat Vibrant Blue Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BOS266 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.66 Carat Vibrant Blue Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BOS266

$2,655.00 USD
$2,950.00 USD
2.14 Carat Round Dark Gray Celestial Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code DSR214 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.14 Carat Round Dark Gray Celestial Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code DSR214 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.14 Carat Round Dark Gray Celestial Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code DSR214

$5,625.00 USD
$6,250.00 USD
2.91 Carat Dark and Clear Emerald Cut Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code DCE291 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.91 Carat Dark and Clear Emerald Cut Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code DCE291 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.91 Carat Dark and Clear Emerald Cut Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code DCE291

$6,525.00 USD
$7,250.00 USD
2.11 Carat Green Fantasy Cut Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code GRFS211 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.11 Carat Green Fantasy Cut Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code GRFS211 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.11 Carat Green Fantasy Cut Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code GRFS211

$4,725.00 USD
$5,250.00 USD
2.35 Carat Dark Oval Salt and Pepper Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code DCO235 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.35 Carat Dark Oval Salt and Pepper Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code DCO235 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.35 Carat Dark Oval Salt and Pepper Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code DCO235

$2,485.00 USD
$3,550.00 USD
2.39 Carat Blue and Yellow Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BYOS239 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.39 Carat Blue and Yellow Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BYOS239 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.39 Carat Blue and Yellow Oval Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code BYOS239

$1,395.00 USD
$1,550.00 USD
2.21 Carat Antique Cushion Cut Teal Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code TCS221 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.21 Carat Antique Cushion Cut Teal Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code TCS221 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.21 Carat Antique Cushion Cut Teal Sapphire for Custom Work - Inventory Code TCS221

$2,115.00 USD
$2,350.00 USD
2.38 Carat Clear Gray Rose or Brilliant Cut Salt and Pepper Pear Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code CCP238 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.38 Carat Clear Gray Rose or Brilliant Cut Salt and Pepper Pear Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code CCP238 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.38 Carat Clear Gray Pear Salt and Pepper Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code CCP238

$5,625.00 USD
$6,250.00 USD
2.58 Carat Black Pear Salt and Pepper Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code NBP258 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.58 Carat Black Pear Salt and Pepper Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code NBP258 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.58 Carat Black Pear Salt and Pepper Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code NBP258

$2,625.00 USD
$3,750.00 USD
2.34 Carat Slightly Opalescent Oval Salt and Pepper Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code SGO234 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry
2.34 Carat Slightly Opalescent Oval Salt and Pepper Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code SGO234 - Midwinter Co. Alternative Bridal Rings and Modern Fine Jewelry

2.34 Carat Opalescent Oval Salt and Pepper Diamond for Custom Work - Inventory Code SGO234

$4,725.00 USD
$5,250.00 USD
At Midwinter Co. Jewelry, we are a sustainable and tiny but trusted small business to create your unique and alternative bride type engagement rings. We are a leader in the salt and pepper diamond world, a quiet luxury brand that works one on one with you to design the most unique, gorgeous, modern jewelry. Midwinter Co. is also one of the only brands that specializes in acutely unique gemstones such as bi-color sapphires, teal green blue sapphires, mossy aquamarine, mossy agate, black tourmaline in quartz, gold in quartz, tourmaline in unique colors, gray sapphires, gray spinel, dark gray spinel, dark gray diamonds, black diamonds, black speckled diamonds, celestial diamonds, galaxy diamonds, dendritic agate, dendritic opal, dendritic quartz, branchy gemstones, quartz with black star hollandite, alexandrite, garnet, peridot with or without tourmaline, harmony quartz aka melody quartz aka seven stone quartz, morganite, emerald, topaz, misty white diamonds, white blue diamonds, opalescent diamonds, opalescent sapphires, parti sapphires, and more. Within our walls, we carry only a small select of stock as much of our work is custom. We custom design and personalize every ring setting/mounting to fit the unique gemstones and diamonds we carry. We can design you a custom ring set based off of a drawing or screen shots, aesthetics, themes, and more. We also have bridal necklaces, bridal earrings, mothers earrings, bridesmaids earrings, modern asymmetrical sapphire diamond earrings and more. Our small team is mighty and caring. Midwinter Co. is top rated with 5/5 100% 5 star on google. Drive 25-35 minutes from Philadelphia to visit our showroom to see our in stock pieces and stones. We can create: couples rings, rings for couples, rings for twins, twins rings, ring sets for couples, matching ring sets, custom stacking rings, custom stacking ring sets, bridal sets, custom right hand rings, custom mother gemstone rings, vintage style rings, modern style engagement rings, rings for the alt-bride, etc. We are LGBTQIA+ friendly, husband and wife owned. Our brand has been featured on E! News, Refinery 29, Vogue UK & magazines nation and internationally. We hope to be a small part of your story. Thank you for being a big part of ours!